Making choices is a skill that is taught. It isn't always there on its own. With autism, it helps to offer two or three clear choices, using pictures or objects, during everyday moments. This way the child feels more in control and more prepared, and resistance to demands often decreases.
Why does choice matter for a child with autism?
A child's daily life is full of decisions made by others: what to wear, when to eat, when to stop playing. When a child has difficulty understanding or predicting what will happen, this feeling of lack of control can intensify anxiety and refusal.
The practical guidelines we reviewed describe offering choices as a preventive strategy that gives the child a sense of having a say and of knowing what to expect. They also note that some children need support to learn how to choose.
Choice has value beyond behavior, too. Having a say in your own daily life is a core part of independence, and this is built from an early age.
What does research show about offering choices?
The evidence is encouraging but limited. Small studies with a single child showed a reduction in challenging behavior when the child could choose between activities, especially when the behavior was related to avoiding a demand. However, such studies are only suggestive and are not enough to draw general conclusions.
A systematic review of choice offered before an activity or as a reward concludes that preference for choice differs from child to child. Some children prefer a choice that leads to something they really love, while others prefer to choose regardless of the outcome. A study comparing programs with and without choice showed the same thing: the same approach does not suit every child.
The takeaway for you: try, observe and adapt to your own child, rather than assuming that more choices are always better.
How do you teach choice-making step by step?
- Start with two choices. Two things the child knows and usually likes, for example “apple or banana?”.
- Make the choices visible. Hold up the objects or show pictures. Spoken language on its own can be difficult.
- Respect the choice. If the child points to or takes something, they get it right away. This teaches them that a choice has a result. If they haven't yet understood the link between choice and result, this step needs repetition.
- Allow different ways of responding. Pointing, looking, a picture, a gesture or a word. For children who speak little, see also alternative means of communication.
- Increase gradually. Once the skill is stable, add a third choice or more open-ended questions.
Where do choices fit into daily life?
The easiest moments are those where the outcome makes no difference to you, but matters to the child:
- which T-shirt or which cup to use
- in which order to do two tasks (e.g. bath first or toys first)
- which toy or book to take on an outing
- where to sit to do homework
You can combine choices with a visual schedule: the child chooses which activity comes first, while the routine as a whole stays stable and predictable.
When does choice not help, or make things harder?
- When there are too many choices. Many options can be confusing. Stick to two or three.
- When there is no real choice. If “do you want to brush your teeth?” has only one acceptable answer, “yes”, it is better to say “first teeth, then a story” and offer a choice only in what can change.
- When the choice requires social guesswork. A review of decision-making in autism reports that for choices requiring self-evaluation or judging others, autistic participants needed more time or avoided choosing. Opt for concrete, visible choices.
- When the child is already in intense distress. At that moment, reducing stimulation comes first. See the guide to meltdowns and shutdowns.
If the child is consistently unable to choose, or choices keep leading to upset, it is worth discussing this with their therapists so the approach can be adapted to their needs.
Frequently asked questions
Should I offer choices with every demand?
No. Some things are not negotiable, such as safety or hygiene. Keep the rule firm and offer a choice in what can change, for example the order, the materials or the way it's done.
My child doesn't speak. Can they make choices?
Yes. Choosing doesn't require speech. It can be done by pointing, looking, using objects, pictures or a communication device. What matters is responding right away, so the child understands that their choice has a result.
They always choose the same thing. What do I do?
This is common, because the familiar feels safe. Keep respecting the choice, and from time to time add one new option next to the favorite, without pressure to try it.
How many choices should I offer?
You usually start with two, and later you can move to three or more. The right number depends on the child: notice whether they stay calm or get lost and refuse.
Is choice enough to stop refusals?
Not on its own. It can help, especially when refusal is linked to avoiding a demand, but the research is limited and children differ. It works best together with predictability, visual support and positive reinforcement.