When a child with autism doesn’t follow an instruction, they often aren’t refusing: they may not have understood it, may need more processing time, or may have been overwhelmed by too many words. Short phrases, one instruction at a time, visual support and several seconds of waiting before you repeat all help.
Why doesn’t the child follow the instruction?
Before you read the child’s behavior as stubbornness, it’s worth looking at what might be going on behind it. The most common explanations are:
- Difficulty understanding language: the child may understand words, but not long or complex sentences.
- Slow processing time: the answer or action comes, but later than we expect.
- Literal interpretation: phrases like “gather up your things” or “do your shoes quickly” may not be clear.
- Overload: when there is noise, tiredness or stress, language becomes harder to process.
- Inattention or difficulty with transitions: the child is absorbed in an activity and finds the change hard.
If you suspect the child doesn’t hear well, a hearing test is always the first step. For the same question about the child’s name, see our article on the child who doesn’t respond to their name.
How do you give an instruction the child can understand?
The National Autistic Society stresses that the language we use directly affects whether the message will be understood. In practice:
- Come close and get their attention. Say their name first and make sure they are paying attention to you, instead of calling out from another room.
- Use few, specific words. “Shoes here” says more than “go and put your things away.”
- One instruction at a time. When the first step is done, give the next one.
- Say what to do, not what not to do. “Walk” is clearer than “don’t run.”
- Avoid figurative expressions and say exactly what you mean.
- Don’t ask several questions at once. One question, and check that it was understood.
How long should I wait before repeating?
Processing time is perhaps the most underestimated factor. The NAS states that we often need to allow a few seconds of silence, and different pages of its site suggest anywhere from about six to at least ten, depending on the person and the situation. The important thing is not to fill the silence with more words, because then processing starts over from the beginning.
If there is no response after the waiting time, repeat the instruction using exactly the same words, preferably with a picture or a gesture. Changing the wording each time can confuse the child, while the same phrase gives them a steady point of reference.
How do pictures and gestures help?
Many children with autism process visual information more easily than spoken language. A literature review on visual supports at home and in the community (PubMed) reports that they can reduce anxiety, increase predictability and support communication and participation. The same authors note that the evidence for their use at home is still limited compared with school.
- Point to the object or use a gesture along with the word.
- Use photos or pictures for the steps of a routine, such as the morning or the evening.
- Try a “first… then…” board for transitions that are difficult.
You’ll find more on how to set them up in our article on visual schedules. As the child makes progress, the supports can gradually be reduced so that dependence doesn’t develop.
When is an assessment needed?
If the child consistently struggles to understand simple instructions, even with short wording and pictures, and this sets them apart from peers, it’s advisable to ask for an assessment of language comprehension. This kind of assessment is done by a speech and language therapist and can show whether targeted support is needed. Often the reason is difficulty understanding, not a lack of effort. For a related picture, see also the article “Understands everything but doesn’t talk”. At Atypical Center, speech and language therapy includes assessment of both expression and comprehension.
Frequently asked questions
My child hears me but doesn’t do what I say. Is it refusal?
Not necessarily. They may not have understood the phrase, may need more time, or may be struggling with the transition. First try shorter wording, a picture and waiting. If the difficulty continues, discuss it with the child’s therapist.
How many steps can a child follow?
It depends on age and language development, and there is no single limit for every child with autism. Start with one instruction and move to two only when the first is done with ease. The speech and language therapist can tell you your child’s level.
Should I repeat the instruction many times?
It’s better to wait a few seconds and then repeat it once, with the same words and visual support. Constant repetition or new wording can confuse the child and increase their anxiety.
What do I do when the child is in a meltdown?
In that moment, limit your talking and avoid new instructions. The priority is safety and calm. Practicing following instructions can happen later, when the child is calm.
Do pictures help even if the child speaks well?
Often, yes. Speaking well doesn’t always mean understanding well, especially with complex phrases. Pictures reduce the load of spoken language and make routines more predictable.