Many parents of children with Autism Spectrum Disorder have heard about music therapy and wonder whether it is worth trying. Music seems to strongly capture the interest of many children on the spectrum, and this has led to decades of research into its use as a therapeutic tool.
The question, however, does not have a simple answer. In recent years, large systematic reviews and clinical studies have given a clearer, though not always unanimous, picture of what music therapy can really offer and where doubts still remain.
What music therapy is
Music therapy is not simply a child listening to music. It is a structured intervention designed and delivered by a certified music therapist, with specific goals for each individual child. Depending on the child’s age and needs, it may include improvising with instruments, singing, rhythmic activities or playing music together. The goals usually relate to communication, interaction, emotional regulation or social participation, not just music education.
What the research shows
An extensive Cochrane review, one of the most rigorous forms of evaluating scientific literature, examined 26 studies with a total of 1,165 participants: children, adolescents and young adults on the spectrum. The findings showed that music therapy probably increases overall improvement by the end of the intervention and probably improves quality of life and the overall severity of autism symptoms, without increasing adverse events. However, it remained unclear whether it specifically affects social interaction or verbal and nonverbal communication, as the certainty of the relevant findings was low to very low.
A larger and more recent randomized clinical trial, known as TIME-A, included 364 children aged 4 to 7 at ten centers internationally and gave a more cautious picture. Improvisational music therapy delivered by specialist therapists did not show a clinically significant improvement in core autism symptoms compared with enhanced standard care, either at five months or at twelve months of follow-up. This finding is a reminder that the results of smaller studies are not always confirmed in larger, more rigorously designed research.
The NICE guideline on autism in children and adolescents itself does not specifically recommend music therapy as a core intervention, precisely because of this weaker and conflicting evidence base. This does not mean that music therapy has no value for some children, but that there is not yet strong enough evidence for it to be recommended as a first-choice intervention for the core symptoms of autism.
Where it may make sense
Taken together, the research shows a picture that varies from child to child, not a single answer for everyone. Some children who show a strong interest in music may respond better to this type of intervention, while others, especially those with sensory hypersensitivity to sounds, may experience it as unpleasant or tiring. For this reason, music therapy makes sense mainly as a complementary tool within a broader, individualized therapy plan, and not as a standalone or exclusive intervention for autism.
- It can play a supporting role for emotional regulation and joint attention.
- It can offer an enjoyable setting for interaction, particularly for children who struggle with more verbal forms of intervention.
- It should not replace evidence-based interventions for speech, occupational therapy or social skills, but should complement them where it suits the particular child.
Questions worth asking
If you are considering adding music therapy to your child’s plan, it is helpful to ask the specialists who work with your child the following.
- What specific goals are being set for the child, and how progress will be assessed along the way.
- Whether the therapist is a certified music therapist with experience working with children on the autism spectrum.
- How music therapy fits into the rest of the child’s intervention plan, alongside speech and language therapy, occupational therapy or social skills groups.
At Atypical Center, music therapy is offered as part of a broader, individualized intervention plan, in both Dafni and Metamorfosi, always combined with the other therapies each child needs.
Key points to remember
Music therapy is not a cure for autism, nor does it guarantee specific results, as is true of any intervention. Research to date shows possible benefits for quality of life and overall functioning, but less clear findings for the core symptoms of communication and social interaction. Whether it is worth including in your child’s plan is best discussed with the team of specialists who work with your child, so that it can be considered in the context of their overall needs.